Harris County commissioners are considering a major expansion of the Public Defender’s Office, with a proposal to add 102 positions as questions emerge about how the county should provide legal representation to people who cannot afford an attorney.
The proposal, listed as Item 327 on Thursday’s Commissioners Court agenda, would add attorneys, investigators and support staff to the office. The positions would be funded through money already approved in the county’s fiscal year 2027 budget.
The expansion is part of a multiyear plan for the Public Defender’s Office to eventually handle 50% of indigent felony and misdemeanor cases in Harris County.
But one longtime criminal defense attorney says the county should be careful about expanding the office at the expense of a system that already relies heavily on private attorneys.
Sylvia Escobedo, a Harris County criminal defense attorney with 31 years of experience as both a prosecutor and defense lawyer, said she is not opposed to expanding the Public Defender’s Office.
She believes the office does good work but argues that private attorneys who accept court-appointed cases are equally important to the criminal justice system.
“I think it’s important on both sides the main focus when you’re representing indigent defendants should be the quality of the representation and the experience of the lawyers,” Escobedo said. “Are they qualified to handle the cases they should be handling?”
Escobedo, who has never worked for the Public Defender’s Office, said she reviewed the county’s proposal and noticed its long-term goal of handling half of indigent defense cases.
She questioned whether that level of expansion is feasible.
According to figures Escobedo said she researched, the Public Defender’s Office currently has fewer than 80 attorneys handling felony cases, compared with more than 450 private attorneys qualified to accept indigent defense appointments.
She also pointed to the county’s significant criminal caseload, saying there are approximately 19,000 pending felony cases in Harris County.
Escobedo believes neither public defenders nor private attorneys could reasonably handle that workload alone.
“There’s a lot of factors at play,” Escobedo said. “I think the county benefits from having both systems in place, the public defender’s office as well as private defense lawyers who handle these cases as well.”
Crime Stoppers of Houston is also weighing in on the proposal, emphasizing that any investment in the criminal justice system should benefit both defendants and crime victims.
In a statement to KPRC 2, the organization said adequate resources are necessary for public defenders, prosecutors, law enforcement and victim services.
The organization warned that overloaded defense attorneys and court backlogs can leave victims and their families waiting months or even years for their cases to be resolved.
Crime Stoppers said any significant expansion of the Public Defender’s Office should come with measurable improvements in case resolution and accountability.
“If additional taxpayer resources are invested, we need to see measurable improvements in case resolution and accountability, while ensuring victims have the support and resources they need throughout the process,” the organization said.
Crime Stoppers also urged county leaders to consider the needs of the District Attorney’s Office and victim services when making funding decisions.
“Our concern is not about choosing between the rights of defendants and the needs of victims. A system that works well must protect both,” the statement said.
Commissioners are scheduled to consider the 102 positions Thursday, Nov. 12.
According to county documents, the proposal would not require additional funding beyond what commissioners have already approved. Instead, the court is being asked to authorize the positions using the existing budget.
If approved, the positions would take effect Nov. 14.
For Escobedo, the issue ultimately comes down to ensuring that people accused of crimes receive qualified legal representation, regardless of whether their attorney works for the county or in private practice.
“I truly believe that both the PDO and private indigent defense attorneys are both an important part of representing indigent defendants,” she said.
KPRC 2 reached out to the Harris County Public Defender’s Office for comment but has not received a response.